1 Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales Bernardino Rivadavia, División Paleoinvertebrados, Av. Ángel Gallardo 470 (C1405DJR), Buenos Aires, Argentina.
trophon@gmail.com
* Corresponding author: trophon@gmail.com
The scarcely known family Condylocardiidae (Bivalvia: Archiheterodonta) is poorly represented in the fossil record and their living representatives are also poorly known. This work presents a new representative of the family from the early Pliocene of marine terrace of Cerro Laciar (Santa Cruz Province). Carditella pitufina sp. nov. is described and characterized by a shell large for the genus, 15 radial ribs as wide as interspaces, high hinge plate and broad and large hinge teeth. The poor record of the family may be due to an identification bias, probably because the tiny size of specimens and its similarity with carditids. This new species resembles to the living Carditella tegulata from southern Argentina and Chile and they could be closely related. Carditella pitufina sp. nov. represents the most ancient record of Carditella in South America and the most ancient record of Condylocardiidae in Argentina.
Keywords: Archiheterodonta, Bivalvia, Carditella, Condylocardiidae, Patagonia, Pliocene.
1. Introduction
The poorly known family Condylocardiidae Bernard, 1896 is characterized by its very small size and narrow hinge with anterior and posterior lateral teeth in each valve (according to Middlefart, 2002a). Major aspects of the biology of condylocardiids are unknown (Middelfart, 2002a). Their tiny size and relative low abundance may be the reason of the scarce knowledge and recognition of living specimens. The family was related to the Carditidae and placed together in the superfamily Carditoidea (Dall, 1903a; Thiele, 1935) and recently was considered a member of the clade Archiheterodonta (Giribet, 2008). Posterior analyses of molecular sequences placed Condylocardiidae as a clade nested within Carditidae (González and Giribet, 2014). This placement agrees with the proposal of Bernard (1897) who considered the condylocardiids derived by neoteny from carditids, and Coan (2003) who suggested a polyphyletic origin for the group.
The Condylocardiidae are frequently distinguished from other archiheterodonts by their tiny size, lateral teeth in both valves, presence of internal ligament, and the presence of large prodissoconchs (Middelfart, 2002b). According other authors (Huber, 2010; Güller and Zelaya, 2013), some genera of condylocardiids present both, internal and external ligament (or exclusively external) and small prodissoconchs. These discrepancies lead to discussions about the taxonomic composition of the family (Middelfart, 2002b; Coan, 2003; Huber, 2010; Coan and Valentich-Scott, 2012).
Living Condylocardiidae were reported from Australia (Middelfart, 2002a, b), tropical eastern Pacific (Coan, 2003), eastern Atlantic (Salas and Rolán, 1990) and southern Atlantic and Pacific (Güller and Zelaya, 2013). Fossil Condylocardiidae were reported from the Paleocene of Nigeria (Adegoke, 1977); Eocene of France (Sanders et al., 2015), United States (Palmer and Brann, 1965), and New Zealand (Maxwell, 1992); Oligocene of United States (Dockery, 1982); Miocene of Australia (Tate, 1886; Ludbrook, 1953), New Zealand (Gage, 1957), Belgium (Louwye et al., 2010), Germany (Moths et al., 2010), and Indonesia (Beets, 1983); Pliocene of New Zealand (Laws, 1940), Belgium (Marquet, 2002), Trinidad and Tobago (Jung, 1969), Indonesia (Oostingh, 1935) and United States (Ward and Blackwelder, 1987); and Quaternary of South Africa (Kensley and Pether, 1986) and Costa Rica (Olsson, 1942). A possible previous record comes from the Cretaceous of North America (Stephenson, 1941) represented by the dubious species Uddenia texana Stephenson, 1941.
There are only three fossil records of the Condylocardiidae in South America. The first is founded in the late Miocene of Uruguay (Camacho Formation) and refers to Warrana antiqua (Figueiras, 1990) (formerly described as Americuna antiqua). The second and third correspond to two mentions listed but not illustrated by Gordillo et al. (2005) from middle Holocene of Tierra del Fuego (Argentina) -Carditella naviformis (Reeve, 1843) and Carditopsis flabellum (Reeve, 1843)-. Nowadays four species of living condylocardiids are mentioned in the region, from southern Peru, Chile and Tierra del Fuego (Güller and Zelaya, 2013). The aim of this contribution is to report and to describe the most ancient fossil record of Condylocardiidae of Argentina, represented by a new species from early Pliocene marine terraces of Santa Cruz (Argentina).
2. Geological setting
Fossil locality of Terrace of Cerro Laciar (Fig. 1), studied by Feruglio (1933, 1950) and assigned to his System Terrace I, are located 50 km west to Puerto Deseado, Santa Cruz Province. These exposures are placed at 170-185 meters above sea level, overlaying the marine Monte León Formation (early Miocene) and consist of few meters of loose gravel with calcareous sandy matrix (Fig. 1). Condylocardiids are founded within the bivalves Scalaricardita laciarina (Feruglio, 1954), Kolmeris tehuelchana (Ihering, 1907), Ostrea ferrarisi d’Orbigny, 1842, “Chlamys” actinodes (Sowerby, 1846), and the gastropods “Trophon” varians (d’Orbigny, 1842) and Pachycymbiola feruglioi (Doello Jurado, 1931). The age of these marine fossiliferous beds has been discussed, and assigned to Miocene (Ameghino, 1906), Pliocene (Feruglio, 1950, 1954) or Pleistocene (Feruglio, 1933). Recently, Del Río et al. (2013) indicated for these deposits an early Pliocene age (5.10±0.21 Ma, Zanclean) based on 87Sr/86Sr analysis from valves of the pectinid “Chlamys” actinodes.
3. Material and methods
The fossil and recent specimens used for comparisons are housed at Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”. Shells were viewed with a Leika binocular magnifying glass. The preservation of fossil shells is moderate, they shows some degree of surface and edge alteration, and bioerosion product of the action of boring sponges -Entobia- (Gordillo et al., 2014). Besides, this attributes did not difficult the identification of morphological features. Hinge terminology follows Lamy (1917), other morphological terms (e.g., “ligamental pit”) follows Middelfart (2002a, b).
Institutional abbreviations. MACN-In (Invertebrates Collecion of the Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”, Buenos Aires, Argentina); MACN-Pi (Paleoinvertebrates Collecion of the Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”, Buenos Aires, Argentina).
Fig. 1. Geographical provenance (indicated by a grey star) of studied fossils and lithological section at Terrace of Cerro Laciar.
4. Systematic paleontology Order Archiheterodonta Remarks. Chavan (1969) and Middelfart (2002a, b) restricted the family for species with an external ligament only and divided the Condylocardiidae in two subfamilies: Condylocardiinae Bernard, 1896 and Cuninae Chavan, 1969. They placed small species with external and internal (Carditella Smith, 1881) or only external ligament (Carditellona Iredale, 1936 and Carditellopsis Iredale, 1936) within the family Carditidae, despite other characters. This approach was not followed by Coan (2003) who considered Carditella as a condylocardiid. Kuroda et al. (1971) suggested a third subfamily, Carditellinae, for these closely related species, following the original concept of Iredale and McMichael (1962) when they grouped the genera Carditellona and Carditellopsis. This approach with three subfamilies instead two was accepted by Huber (2010) and is followed here. Carditellinae taxa share with the Cuninae the presence of a small and poorly defined cup-shaped prodissoconch and triangular-shaped right middle and left posterior teeth. Genus Carditella Smith, 1881 Type species. Carditella pallida Smith, 1881 by subsequent designation (Dall, 1903b) (Recent, southern Chile) (junior synonym of Carditella tegulata according to Güller and Zelaya, 2013). Emended diagnosis. Shell small and flabellate. Lunule elongated. External sculpture of 11-15 radial ribs. Hinge composed by two left cardinal and three right cardinal teeth. Each valve also has two lateral teeth, one nearly marginal on the one side, the other on the opposite side being well within the outer edge, with a groove between it and the anterior margin. External and internal ligament small, internal placed beneath the apex of the valves in a small resilifer (Modified from Smith, 1881). Remarks. In its original description, Smith (1881) recognized that external sculpture resembles carditids. The genus Carditella is characterized by their flabellate shell-outline with wide radial ribs covered by subrectangular nodes, hinge with two left and three right cardinal teeth and anterior and posterior lateral teeth in both valves. Also, Carditella has external and internal ligament, the latter marked by a ligamental pit beneath the apex in left valve. The presence of strongly developed lateral teeth and a small ligamental pit allow to place the new species in the condylocardiid genus Carditella. Hinge configuration and external sculpture do not differ from other species of Carditella. Two fossil species of Carditella were recorded: C. baloguni Adegoke, 1977 (late Paleocene, Nigeria) and C. aldrichi (Casey, 1903) (middle Eocene-early Oligocene, United States of America). Carditella calipsamma Carrington and Kensley, 1969 (late Pliocene-early Pleistocene, South Africa) seems to be a representative of the genus Carditellona Iredale, 1936 instead a southern African Carditella species. Nowadays, the genus Carditella is represented by C. naviformis (Reeve, 1843) (southern South America), C. tegulata (Reeve, 1843) (southern Peru to Tierra del Fuego), C. semen (Reeve, 1843) (southern Peru to Chile), C. exulata Smith, 1885 (Tristan da Cunha), C. galapagana Coan, 2003 (western coast of Colombia and Galapagos Islands), C. marieta Coan, 2003 (western coast of Mexico), C. capensis Smith, 1885 (Recent, Angola and South Africa), C. delli Crozier, 1966 (northern New Zealand), C. iejimensis Hayami and Kase, 1993 (southern Japan), C. laticosta Smith, 1904 (South Africa), C. mawsoni Dell, 1972 (Weddel Sea), and C. tridacnula Oliver and Chesney, 1997 (Oman). Carditella pitufina sp. nov. Etymology. The specific epithet refers to the Belgian comic characters created by Peyo, “Les Schtroumpfs” (called “The Smurfs” in English and “Los Pitufos” in Spanish speaker countries). These creatures are characterized by their tiny sizes as the condylocardiids bivalves. This epithet is expressed in Spanish diminutive form to emphasize the reference. Type material Holotype MACN-Pi 6344 (a left valve). Paratype MACN-Pi 6344 (a left and three right valves). Type locality and horizon. Terrace of Cerro Laciar, Santa Cruz Province (lower Pliocene marine terraces). Diagnosis. Shell large for the genus (length range 6.27-7.12 mm), external sculpture of 15 radial ribs as wide as interspaces, hinge plate high and hinge teeth broad and large. Description. Shell large-sized for the genus (length range 6.27-7.12 mm) (Table 1), mainly subtriangular; convex anterior and posterior margins, rounded ventral margin, dorsal margin sharply sloping and very curved, angle between dorsal and posterior margins smooth, angle between dorsal and anterior margins weak marked. Umbo small, pointed or slightly rounded, anteriorly directed, placed at centre to anterior third of the valve length. Lunule large, elongated and narrow, slightly concave, without sculpture and smoothly separated from remaining surface of shell. Escutcheon large and elongated, smooth, larger than lunule. Prodissoconch small, eroded in all specimens studied. Hinge plate high, three cardinal and two lateral teeth in right valve and two cardinal and two lateral teeth in left valve. Right valve hinge with rounded ventral edge; anterior cardinal tooth thin and straight, anteriorly inclined; middle cardinal tooth subtriangular, slightly inclined posteriorly, with broad base; posterior cardinal tooth thin, long and straight; anterior lateral tooth elongated, wide, separated from lunular margin; posterior lateral tooth elongated, high, not differentiated from anterior margin. Left valve hinge with a straight ventral edge; anterior cardinal tooth curved, anteriorly inclined, with broad base; posterior cardinal tooth long and curved, inclined posteriorly, with broad base and acute apex; anterior lateral tooth thin and high, close to anterior margin; posterior lateral tooth long and wider than anterior lateral. Small ligamental pit placed below beak in left hinge. External sculpture of 15 radial ribs as wide as interspaces, with subrectangular transverse section, covered by rectangular nodes; interspaces with subrectangular transverse section. Pallial line at a quarter of total valve height. Inner ventral margin crenulated; crenulations subrectangular and truncated, covering the entire margin.
|