1 Laboratorio de Paleontología de Vertebrados, Centro de Investigaciones Científicas y Transferencia de Tecnología a la Producción (CICYTTP, CONICET)-Provincia de ER-UADER, Materi y España, E3105BWA, Diamante, Entre Ríos, Argentina.
gschmidt@cicyttp.org.ar
2 Paleontología, IANIGLA, CCT-CONICET Mendoza, Avda. Ruiz Leal s/n, 5500 Mendoza, Argentina.
espe@mendoza-conicet.gob.ar; stgo86@gmail.com
* Corresponding author: gschmidt@cicyttp.org.ar
In this contribution we present new specimens of Litopterna recovered during the last decade in Quebrada Fiera (Mendoza Province, Argentina), whose fossiliferous sediments, currently recognized as the base of Agua de la Piedra Formation, are assignable to Late Oligocene (Deseadan South American Land Mammal Age). Two remains mentioned in the first publication on this locality were neither detailed nor described, and they have not been located in the corresponding repository. The new material consists of postcranial fragmentary remains (astragali, calcaneum, and metapodials) of Macraucheniidae (Cramaucheniinae) and an incomplete upper molar (M3) of Proterotheriidae (Proterotheriinae). These few remains of litopterns contrast with the abundance of notoungulates at Quebrada Fiera. A comparative study was carried out with material from Patagonia (Argentina) and taxa recorded in Bolivia and Peru for the same temporal interval. The specimens of Cramaucheniinae are assigned to Coniopternium andinum and the molar of Proterotheriinae to cf. Lambdaconus suinus. This contribution allows us to extend the geographical range of Coniopternium, filling the gap between the Patagonian and lower latitude localities (Bolivia and Peru) in which this genus was found. The record of L. suinus in Quebrada Fiera expands the geographical range of this species outside from Patagonia.
Keywords: Litopterna, Coniopternium andinum, Lambdaconus suinus, Deseadan SALMA, Mendoza.
1. Introduction
The order Litopterna comprises several families of South American Native Ungulates (SANU). It has been recorded from the Early Paleocene (Bonaparte and Morales, 1997) to the Late Pleistocene/Early Holocene in South America (Tonni, 1990; Bond, 1999; Schmidt and Ferrero, 2014), and the Eocene in West Antarctica (Gelfo et al., 2015). There are various Paleogene groups (i.e., Amilnedwardsiidae, Anisolambdidae, Indalecidae, Notonychopidae, Protolipternidae and Sparnotheriodontidae) that are commonly included in the order, but their relationships with Adianthidae, Macraucheniidae and Proterotheriidae are not well established (Cifelli, 1993; Rose, 2006; Forasiepi et al., 2016).
Phylogenetic relationships of SANU with other extant mammals still remain unresolved, with two different hypotheses following recent phylogenetic analyses at a large scale in which only a few taxa of SANU are included. One hypothesis relates the genera Thomashuxleya Ameghino, 1901 and Carodnia Simpson, 1935 to Proboscidea and Sirenia, forming the clade Paenungulata within Afrotheria, whereas the genus Protolipterna Cifelli, 1983 is related to didolodontids and other Condylarthra, being close to the clade Eungulata (O’Leary et al., 2013); therefore, the three genera of SANU included in the analysis are not recovered as a clade. The second hypothesis is based on proteomic analyses and recovers the two included genera of SANU (Macrauchenia Owen, 1838 and Toxodon Owen, 1837) as a clade that is the sister taxon of Perissodactyla (Buckley, 2015; Welker et al., 2015). More recently, a new study using mitochondrial genome (Westbury et al., 2017) places Macrauchenia patachonica (and thus Litopterna) as the sister taxon of living Perissodactyla, in agreement with prior works based on collagen sequences obtained from proteomic analyses.
Macraucheniidae (Late Oligocene-Late Pleistocene/Early Holocene; Schmidt and Ferrero, 2014) currently comprises two subfamilies: Cramaucheniinae and Macraucheniinae (Soria, 1981; Dozo and Vera, 2010; Schmidt and Ferrero, 2014; Forasiepi et al., 2016), while Proterotheriidae (Late Paleocene-Late Pleistocene, Villafañe et al., 2006) is composed of Anisolambdinae, Megadolodinae and Proterotheriinae (Cifelli and Villarroel, 1997; Villafañe et al., 2006, 2012; Schmidt, 2015). Macraucheniids include medium to very large herbivores with body masses estimated about 35.3-54.6 kg for Llullataruca shockeyi McGrath et al., 2018, 121 kg for Theosodon gracilis Ameghino, 1891, 250 kg for Huayqueriana cf. H. cristata (Rovereto, 1914), 400 kg for Promacrauchenia Ameghino, 1904, 830-1100 kg for Macrauchenia patachonica, and 1200 kg for Macraucheniopsis ensenadensis Paula-Couto, 1945 (Fariña et al., 1998; Cassini et al., 2012; Vizcaíno et al., 2012; Forasiepi et al., 2016; McGrath et al., 2018). Other characteristics of macraucheniids are long neck and limbs, three digits, complete dentition and browser-grazer or typically browser diet (Bond, 1999; Cassini et al., 2012; Croft, 2016). Their nares were positioned posteriorly with very small nasal bones in macraucheniines such as Huayqueriana, Macrauchenia and Xenorhinotherium Cartelle and Lessa, 1988 (Schmidt and Ferrero, 2014; Forasiepi et al., 2016), although primitive forms (e.g., Cramauchenia Ameghino, 1902) present the nasal notch anteriorly placed (Dozo and Vera, 2010).
Proterotheriids comprise small to medium-sized herbivores, characterized by the reduction of lateral digits (II and IV). Their body mass ranges from ~10 kg for Lambdaconus colombianus (Hoffstetter and Soria, 1986) to ~395 kg for Diplasiotherium robustum Rovereto, 1914 (Ortiz Jaureguizar et al., 2003; Villafañe et al., 2006), though the latter seems to be overestimated. According to Soria (2001:97), the skull of D. robustum was around 30 cm similar to that of the macraucheniid Theosodon, but body mass estimations for the latter are rather smaller (e.g., 125-170 kg for T. lallemanti, Croft, 2016). For the proterotheriids of Santacrucian SALMA, Cassini et al. (2012) calculated a mean body mass from ~24 kg (Thoatherium minusculum Ameghino, 1887) to ~82 kg (Diadiaphorus majusculus Ameghino, 1887). These values are lower than those calculated by Villafañe (2005), but close to those provided by Croft (2016; e.g., T. minusculum: 15-28 kg). Proterotheriids occupied diverse environments, from forested to semi-open areas (Bond et al., 2001, Ubilla et al., 2011). The Santacrucian Thoatherium exhibited a noticeable tendency towards monodactyly, due to a reduction of the lateral digits even greater than in Equinae horses. This is why proterotheriids have been usually compared with little horses (Soria, 2001; Bond et al., 2001).
Since 2006, new field works to Quebrada Fiera locality (Mendoza Province, central-west Argentina) have greatly increased the knowledge of its Deseadan fauna that encompasses typical Patagonian taxa, exclusive elements and a species shared with Salla, Bolivia (Cerdeño, 2011, 2014a, b; Cerdeño and Reguero, 2015; Cerdeño and Vera, 2010, 2014, 2015, 2017; Cerdeño et al., 2010; Forasiepi et al., 2014; Hernández del Pino et al., 2017; Miquel and Cerdeño, 2016; Seoane and Cerdeño, 2014; Vera et al., 2017). In this opportunity, this contribution focuses on the Litopterna from Quebrada Fiera, a group whose presence at this locality was only referred to as Macraucheniidae indet. (Gorroño et al., 1979), mentioning two specimens stored at MLP (Museo de La Plata, Buenos Aires, Argentina), which have not been located at present. We include herein a full description of the new remains, their comparison with other Deseadan taxa and some biogeographical remarks.
2. Geological context
The Quebrada Fiera site is situated in the Malargüe Department, south of Mendoza Province, Argentina, at the foothill of the Andes Range (Fig. 1). The fossiliferous levels are located at around 36°33’13.3”S, 69°42’3.5”W, 1300-1406 m of altitude. The site was discovered during a geological prospection carried out by Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales (YPF) in the late seventies (Gorroño et al., 1979). Later on, other fossil bearing levels were found at the southern side of the ravine, located at around 36°33’26”S, 69°41’35”W, 1316 m (see Cerdeño and Vera, 2014, 2017).
The geological characterization and the preliminary faunal list were published by Gorroño et al. (1979). The faunal assemblage was then assigned to the Late Oligocene (Deseadan SALMA) based on the presence of two typical representatives of the Deseadean fauna of Patagonia: Pyrotherium Ameghino, 1888 and Proborhyaena gigantea Ameghino, 1897 (Gorroño et al., 1979; Bond and Pascual, 1983; Cerdeño and Vera, 2017). New faunal data confirm the Deseadan age, but absolute dating is lacking for Quebrada Fiera.
The stratigraphic section consists of a heterogeneous conglomeradic level, followed by uniform sequences, variable in thickness, of whitish-ocher tuffaceous paleosols with concretions and whitish-gray tuffs with intercalations of pyroclastic deposits (Gorroño et al., 1979). These deposits are currently recognized as the base of the Agua de la Piedra Formation (Combina and Nullo, 2008, 2011; Cerdeño and Vera, 2014).
3. Material and methods
The final repository of the new material studied is the Museo de Ciencias Naturales y Antropológicas “J.C. Moyano” (MCNAM) in Mendoza city, Argentina. Most remains correspond to postcranial elements (fragments of metapodials, astragali and one calcaneum) and there is only one incomplete upper molar (M3). The taxonomic identification was based on morphological and metrical comparisons with other Deseadan specimens from Argentina (Patagonia) through direct observation or published data. The compared material corresponds to specimens housed in the following institutions: ACM (Pratt Museum, Amherst College, Amherst, USA); AMNH (American Museum of Natural History, New York, USA); FMNH (Field Museum of Natural History, Chicago, USA); MACN-A (Museo Argentino de Ciencias Naturales “Bernardino Rivadavia”, Colección Ameghino, Buenos Aires, Argentina); MNHN-Bol (Departamento de Paleontología, Museo Nacional de Historia Natural, La Paz, Bolivia); MUSM (Departamento de Paleontología de Vertebrados, Museo de Historia Natural, Universidad Mayor de San Marcos, Lima, Perú); UF (Vertebrate Paleontology Collection, Florida Museum of Natural History, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA).
Fig. 1.Geographical location of Quebrada Fiera site, Mendoza Province, Argentina (modified from Cerdeño and Vera, 2017).
4. Systematic paleontology Litopterna Ameghino, 1889 Material. astragali: MCNAM-PV 4490, left (complete); MCNAM-PV 4489, left head fragment; MCNAM-PV 4904, right trochlea fragment; MCNAM-PV 5250 and MCNAM-PV 5251, two trochlea portions. Calcaneum: MCNAM-PV 4092, proximal fragment. Metapodials: MCNAM-PV 3859, MCNAM-PV 4256, MCNAM-PV 4264, and MCNAM-PV 4275, distal fragments. Occurrence. . Quebrada Fiera locality, Malargüe Department, Mendoza Province, Argentina. Base of the Agua de la Piedra Formation, Late Oligocene, Deseadan SALMA. Descriptions. the astragalus MCNAM-PV 4490 (Fig. 2A) has the trochlea rather symmetric. The external crest is slightly more developed and acute than the medial one and both are parallel to the astragalar body; this is also observed in the fragment MCNAM-PV 4904 (Fig. 2B). The neck is narrower than the trochlea, short, and in dorsal view, the fossa is slightly displaced to the lateral side. The articulation with the navicular is dorsoventrally convex with a dorsolateral expansion (also observed in MCNAM-PV 4489). In ventral view (Fig. 2A), the sustentacular facet is slightly depressed and with a proximodistal enlargement. There is a little astragalar foramen at the end of the astragalar groove that separates the ectal and sustentacular facets. The other fragments of astragali (MCNAM-PV 5250 and 5251) are coincident in morphology and measurements (Table 1) with MCNAM-PV 4490. The calcaneum MCNAM-PV 4092 (Fig. 2C) preserves a long neck, laterally compressed and dorsoventrally broad. The medial and lateral sides are slightly depressed, and its dorsal border is narrower than the ventral one. The tuber is enlarged, subtriangular, rugose, and proximally projected. All metapodials assigned to macraucheniids are distal fragments (Figs. 2D-F), one of them badly preserved and not figured. They present a strong keel, slightly displaced from the center, which occupies the whole length of the trochlea, being more prominent on the ventral side (better observed in the most complete specimen MCNAM-PV 3859, Fig. 2D). Ventrally and above the keel, there is a median ridge on the diaphysis (Fig. 2D-F). At both sides of the trochlea as well as above its ventral border, there are depressions for ligament insertions. In MCNAM-PV 3859, MCNAM-PV 4264 and MCNAM-PV 4275 (Figs. 2D-F), the asymmetry of the trochlea is interpreted as belonging to lateral digits. Comments and comparison. the Macraucheniidae recognized for Deseadan SALMA are Coniopternium andinum Ameghino, 1894 (including Notodiaphorus crassus Loomis, 1914; Cifelli and Soria, 1983), ?C. primitivum Cifelli and Soria, 1983, Pternoconius polymorphoides Cifelli and Soria, 1983, and Cramauchenia normalis Ameghino, 1902 (including C. insolita Ameghino, 1902; Soria, 1981). Morphologically, the astragalus MCNAM-PV 4490 (Fig. 2A) is undifferentiated from those assigned to Coniopternium andinum from La Flecha, Santa Cruz Province (MACN A-11701-02; Figs. 3A, B), from Cabeza Blanca, Chubut Province (MACN A-12206 and MACN A-12207; Figs. 3E, F), and that figured by Loomis (1914, Fig. 11 as Notodiaphorus crassus) also from Cabeza Blanca locality. Concerning the latter, Loomis indicated a tiny facet for the cuboid that is not observed either in MCNAM-PV 4490 or the Patagonian specimens. Similarities are also evident with the Bolivian specimens UF 172424 of ?Coniopternium sp. from the Principle Guide Level, Unit 4, at Calaboza Pata, and UF 172426 of Coniopternium cf. C. primitivum from Unit II at Pasto Grande (Shockey, 1999; Shockey and Anaya, 2008). The very little astragalar foramen described in MCNAM-PV 4490 is also observed in MACN A-12207 (Fig. 3F) and UF 172426. In turn, according to Shockey (1999), there would be a cuboid facet in UF 172426, but practically indistinct from the sustentacular facet; in fact, the author established the contact astragalus-cuboid after the presence of a facet in the cuboid, and suggested that this contact would occur only during the loaded portion of the locomotor cycle. In contrast, MCNAM-PV 4490 is morphologically different from the astragalus of Cramauchenia normalis (MACN A-12238, Fig. 3G) described by Soria (1981). In dorsal view, the specimen from Mendoza has more concave trochlea, longer neck and wider head. Even though MACN A-12238 is ventrally eroded, it shows a similar astragalar foramen, but slightly displaced dorsally with respect to MCNAM-PV 4490.
|